{
  "status": "independent_numerical_pass_with_disclosed_source_balance_failures",
  "observation_year": 2022,
  "reviewed_on": "2026-09-23",
  "review_kind": "Second AI agent computational and prose check, not external human peer review",
  "raw_csv_sha256": "fbab8fd2727bda9fd8c6cfee8227816db82d33bef6aa4b90194ca5dcbc5ad14b",
  "method": "Independent standard-library CSV parsing;164 transposed RHS:81VA origins,81TLS origins,signed input-balance residual,absolute input-gap diagnostic. No analysis-code imports.",
  "numerical_comparison_status": "PASS",
  "result_cells": 9,
  "origin_rows": 729,
  "maximum_absolute_differences": {
    "nine_result_rows": {
      "usd_mn": 7.411399792489615e-10,
      "percentage_points": 5.329070518200751e-15
    },
    "729_origin_rows": {
      "usd_mn": 2.9103830456733704e-11,
      "percentage_points": 2.842170943040401e-14
    }
  },
  "known_failed_source_conditions": [
    {
      "name": "output_row_balance",
      "status": "FAIL",
      "detail": {
        "independent": 238.60580000001937,
        "reported": 0.0,
        "absolute_difference": 238.60580000001937,
        "allowed": 0.22685000000000002
      }
    },
    {
      "name": "output_column_balance",
      "status": "FAIL",
      "detail": {
        "independent": 82.03199999779918,
        "reported": 0.0,
        "absolute_difference": 82.03199999779918,
        "allowed": 0.20265
      }
    }
  ],
  "source_provenance_status": "Archived raw member matches included producer hash; current OECD ZIP byte identity not established",
  "figure_check_status": "PASS:18 comparison bars,54 accounting segments,axis/row/numeric labels;PNG visual inspection",
  "prose_review_status": "PASS after dollar-maximum versus relative-maximum wording clarified",
  "tested_study_files_sha256": {
    "results.csv": "0839b92af506fd94d9d818e80698fe85899b3cefbb4ad35149713c21cf54b199",
    "all-origin-reconciliation.csv": "4ceccbe5516424dae98a8bc8252fa281855f9cbca51578945dc4f0a028a21a75",
    "validation.json": "5aa5081567a159eab5d5f02668f9d24793c42f5c1f6ae8443ea59e3bf39039e1",
    "source-manifest.json": "d1e8fc69aaca9c6bd4ce09e245aeaea07acf39a10613832cf6881af591ccfbb1",
    "summary.json": "babbd2f83a628929174ab69733dbd1783095d9aa7344369807f596887c14ca8a",
    "frozen-scope.json": "9f09e89ac8d7532135c824c1e11b23ab321373db2164a3613dd97b502cb052e9",
    "china-us-shares-2022.svg": "31ba1775fc34372a30eb37f3f97d5f8e9eaf2cd68a42ccb340b84f5a1151b0fe",
    "china-us-shares-2022.png": "f11fd6eac8f87d4a55b0ffc9db1d15c3a7466dc8c105d72640b9a52571c2734b",
    "origin-accounting-2022.svg": "e61b92f1c49f0e94ded4660035573eeaa528613df148069e3c530033730d0a38",
    "origin-accounting-2022.png": "ded4a74c9123f70bfe56b2ebeee7091784079d589c73fb2ae1c1e265f96efda8",
    "REPORT.md": "fe580246f29ebef7e633f85defcad7fa18c592672b24a46bb67169d66f95e547",
    "policy-brief.md": "324e330f00841c900dd35e2f459b9074cee9da12e6f33f8059964076c90b686d",
    "publication.json": "33bd59739a2f10a3a6d77225c323effe5a3f6f76fd7725e47fe53d27544ddccb"
  }
}